
Criminal Compliance: the Supreme Court acquits a company convicted of international corruption and reaffirms the requirements for corporate criminal liability
Supreme Court Judgment 544/2026 of 21 September confirms that an offence committed by a senior executive does not automatically entail criminal liability for the company and that such liability requires proof of an independent basis for attribution, linked to organisational deficiencies. The judgment also recalls that acts of international corruption may occur during the performance of lawfully awarded contracts.
The Criminal Chamber of the Spanish Supreme Court, in Judgment No. 544/2026 of 21 September (ECLI:ES:TS:2026:3864), has delivered an important ruling concerning criminal Compliance, corporate criminal liability and corruption in international business transactions.
The judgment upholds the convictions of two company representatives for international corruption but acquits one of the companies involved because the proven facts did not identify the organisational deficiencies necessary to establish its criminal liability.
In doing so, the Supreme Court reaffirms its doctrine of corporate self-responsibility and recalls that an offence committed by an executive or employee, even when acting on behalf of or for the benefit of the organisation, does not justify presuming defects in its prevention, monitoring and control mechanisms.
- The case: international corruption during the performance of a contract
The events examined arose in the context of several contracts for the supply of defence equipment concluded between a Spanish state-owned commercial company and the government of a foreign country.
During the performance of a project to supply coastal surveillance systems and vessels, an executive of the contracting company and a representative of a subcontractor participated in granting improper advantages to foreign public officials and persons close to them.
These advantages included gifts, travel, hotel stays, industrial equipment and medical expenses, including cosmetic surgery for relatives of certain officials.
Some of these expenses were included in contractual invoices under descriptions concealing their true nature. Certain communications between those involved also revealed steps intended to disguise the delivery of goods unrelated to the contracts.
According to the proven facts, the purpose of these advantages was to secure the goodwill and cooperation of the foreign officials in order to facilitate the performance and continuation of the contractual relationships.
The Spanish National Court convicted the two company representatives and the subcontracting company of an offence of corruption in international business transactions. However, the Supreme Court upheld the convictions of the individuals and acquitted the company.
- International corruption can also occur in lawfully awarded contracts
One of the most significant aspects of the judgment for Compliance and anti-corruption systems is its interpretation of the offence of corruption in international business transactions, formerly provided for in Article 445 of the Spanish Criminal Code and now regulated by Article 286 ter.
Among other arguments, the defence maintained that the contracts had been properly concluded and performed, with no evidence of any distortion of the conditions of competition in their award.
However, the Supreme Court rejects this interpretation and recalls that the offence of international corruption is not confined to conduct intended to obtain a contract improperly; it also covers conduct intended to retain a contract by granting improper advantages to foreign public officials.
Accordingly, a lawfully awarded and properly performed contract may provide the setting for corrupt conduct where improper benefits are granted to ensure its continuation or maintain a favourable competitive position.
The Supreme Court also clarifies that the corrupting potential of an improper advantage depends neither solely on its monetary value nor on its proportionality to the contract value, but rather on its objective capacity to exert improper influence over the conduct of the official receiving it.
This interpretation is particularly relevant to organisations operating internationally, since it demonstrates that anti-corruption controls must cover every stage of the contractual relationship and must not be restricted to negotiation and award procedures.
- Criminal Compliance and corporate criminal liability: why was the company acquitted?
The second issue, of particular relevance from a criminal Compliance perspective, concerns the requirements for attributing criminal liability to a legal person under Article 31 bis of the Spanish Criminal Code.
The Supreme Court reaffirms its doctrine of corporate self-responsibility, under which an organisation’s criminal liability cannot be based exclusively on an offence committed by one of its directors, executives or employees.
The Chamber recalls that the so-called corporate offence requires an independent basis for attribution, linked to the existence of a structural deficiency in the prevention, monitoring and supervision mechanisms required of the legal person.
Consequently, it is not enough to establish that an individual committed an offence on behalf of or for the benefit of the company. The requirements for attributing criminal liability to the organisation itself must also be established.
In the case under consideration, the Supreme Court finds that the judgments under appeal contained no reference in their statements of proven facts to organisational deficiencies at the subcontracting company capable of establishing its criminal liability.
The absence of a sufficient factual basis precludes upholding the company’s conviction, even though the criminal liability of its representative had been established.
The judgment thus reinforces an essential distinction: criminal liability of a legal person does not arise automatically from the criminal liability of an individual; it requires an autonomous basis.
- The Supreme Court rejects any presumption of organisational deficiency
One of the most legally significant aspects of the judgment is that the Supreme Court rejects the proposition that an offence committed by an executive or employee gives rise to a presumption of organisational deficiency within the company.
The Chamber recalls that legal persons under investigation or facing criminal charges enjoy the guarantees arising from the fundamental right to the presumption of innocence.
It is therefore unacceptable to apply a less demanding standard of proof to legal persons than to individuals, or automatically to transfer the criminal consequences of individual conduct to an organisation.
In this regard, the Supreme Court emphasises that corporate criminal liability must be based on established facts identifying structural deficiencies in the organisation’s prevention and control mechanisms.
This doctrine, which builds on previous judgments including Supreme Court Judgments 154/2016 of 29 February, 221/2016 of 16 March and 372/2025 of 11 April, reinforces the distinction between individual criminal liability and corporate criminal liability.
The Chamber also warns that the analysis cannot be limited to determining who bears the burden of proving the existence of Compliance programmes or the applicability of a possible exemption from liability.
The issue arises at an earlier stage: before a legal person can be criminally convicted, the requirements establishing its own criminal liability must be proven.
At this point, it is particularly important to distinguish between two situations:
- The absence of criminal liability because the relevant requirements have not been proven. Where the independent basis for attributing liability to a legal person has not been established, no conviction may be entered.
- Exemption from criminal liability where the statutory requirements are met. In this case, the analysis focuses on whether the conditions laid down in Article 31 bis of the Spanish Criminal Code are satisfied so that the corresponding exemption may apply.
In the case examined, the company’s acquittal was not based on proof that its Criminal Compliance System was effective, but on the fact that the conviction did not set out the facts necessary to support the company’s criminal liability.
The judgment therefore cannot be construed as a finding by the Supreme Court that the organisation’s prevention and control mechanisms were adequate or effective. Rather, the Court considered that the factual basis for its conviction was insufficient.
- What are the implications of this judgment for Compliance Systems?
Supreme Court Judgment 544/2026 provides important lessons for companies and professionals responsible for designing, implementing and overseeing Compliance Systems.
First, it demonstrates the need to assess corruption risks throughout the entire contractual lifecycle. Corrupt conduct is not confined to negotiation and award stages; it may also occur during the performance, amendment, renewal or continuation of contracts.
In this context, particular importance attaches to controls over dealings with public authorities, the approval of gifts and hospitality, the appointment and oversight of intermediaries, the substantiation of entertainment expenses, and the traceability of payments and benefits.
Second, it highlights the importance of effective prevention, monitoring and supervision mechanisms, tailored to the risks and characteristics of each organisation.
Criminal Compliance Systems must be translated into specific, operational measures, with clearly assigned responsibilities and monitoring arrangements that make it possible to verify their effective implementation.
Finally, it underlines the importance of documented information and evidence demonstrating that the Compliance System is operating. Although the judgment focuses primarily on the requirements for corporate criminal liability and the associated evidential standards, its reasoning highlights the value of organisations being able to demonstrate the measures adopted to prevent, detect and manage their criminal risks.
In any event, it should be recalled that the existence of a Criminal Compliance System does not automatically give rise to an exemption from liability, just as an offence committed by an executive does not, in itself, prove that the System is ineffective or suffers from structural deficiencies.
- Conclusion: the importance of criminal Compliance and an independent basis for corporate liability
Supreme Court Judgment 544/2026 is particularly significant for criminal Compliance, both in its interpretation of the offence of international corruption and in its treatment of the basis for corporate criminal liability.
First, it confirms that a lawfully awarded and properly performed contract may become the setting for corrupt practices where improper advantages are granted to ensure its continuation.
Second, it reaffirms that an offence committed by an executive or employee does not automatically entail criminal liability for the company, which requires an independent basis for attribution linked to structural deficiencies in its prevention and control mechanisms.
The judgment thus consolidates an essential safeguard in the application of Article 31 bis of the Spanish Criminal Code: corporate criminal liability must be based on sufficiently established facts, and an organisational deficiency cannot be presumed merely because an individual offence has occurred.
From a Compliance perspective, this doctrine reinforces the importance of effective prevention and control systems tailored to each organisation’s risks and supported by evidence demonstrating their implementation and oversight.